The Dangers of Homeschooling Dogma
by Beverley Paine, Nov 1999
When Roger was born I shared the maternity ward with a young mother who chose to bottle feed her newborn infant. I'd always breastfed my babies, not really thinking there was any other way, fulling subscribing to the propaganda that 'breast is best'. This young woman had much to teach me, not just about parenting, but about the very nature of dogma.
The young woman I shared the ward with had quite a different education. Unable to pass the critical IQ test she was positioned within an education system that clearly limited her options and denied development of her educational potential. The lessons she encountered everyday gave her the basics only, and never sought to challenge or provide moments for the development of critical thinking ability or research skills. She was never pegged for a leadership role in society, and her education reaffirmed her position as a follower. It was easier for her to replicate the traditions within her own family and small country community.
On the other hand my education demanded that I challenge traditional wisdom, often bringing me into conflict with the community I lived with, and to derive support and solace I needed to turn away from family and friends and depend more and more upon books by 'experts'. I lost contact with people and became very lonely. I comforted myself by knowing that my children were getting that all important opportunity to bond that breast feeding offers. My loneliness, I reasoned, was due to my own bottle fed child hood.
The woman in the bed next to me knew that breast feeding was 'superior', and it was something that she'd liked to have been able to do, but it was much too hard. The odds were against it. As I listened to her reasons I knew I had all the answers to counter them - I'd read them all in the Nursing Mothers Newsletters I'd brought with me to the hospital. I could have easily quoted them all. After all I had needed them to argue my infant feeding choices and routines to my own mother, and to my mother in law.
Her support structures included people who probably never read as widely as I did, or accessed the many community resources I needed as a new resident in the area. I could see that to struggle with breastfeeding once she left hospital would be overwhelming compared with ease and complete support that bottle feeding would offer. Decades of bottle feeding propaganda had done their work, and in this small country community the trendy move to breastfeeding, already more than a decade old, hadn't filtered through. I doubted that it ever would.
My support structures were primarily derived from my reading, and from seeking out other highly educated mothers, who favoured and promoted reading. I never really felt part of that group, though, coming from a working class background and not having obtained a university education. I really felt a part of the social group that the young woman in the maternity ward belonged to, but my elitist education set me aside.
Information can only get you so far. As social animals we really need to interact with people, and derive our social learning from these interactions, not from books.
As a home educating parent, one who supports and promotes networking and dissemination of information, I am careful to remember that woman in hospital, and how we supported each other in our baby feeding choices. I feel this is something we should all strive to do. Regardless of how we chose to home educate, what philosophy or methodology we choose we can all support each other choices, knowing that the important thing is the nurturing of the young minds in our care.
There is danger in blindly promoting a particular dogma, in much the same way there is danger in trying to teach a child something without taking into consideration that child's particular learning needs and styles. It is ever so easy to alienate people, to offend them, to bully them into reluctant compliance and thus build resentment instead of true friendship. Slowly but surely communication diminishes until, too late, relationships disappear altogether. This happens within families and within communities. If you can express your principles or opinions without arrogance, without the need to recruit or convert your listeners, then you will avoid these problems. But so few of us manage to do this, unfortunately.
I was lucky to keep my knowledge about breast feeding to myself those few days in hospital, and although I felt guilty about my silence, knowing that one child was missing out on such a great start to life, I knew that her mother felt supported about her parenting choices. She would go home and happily nurture her child in the time honoured way of four hourly feeds, training her baby to sleep through the night, progressive weight gains, and a family to help out with the feeding routine.
Later I became involved with Nursing Mothers, a self help support network, much like the homeschooling ones I see springing up around the country. However, over time I found myself facing a growing problem, one we continually face in society whenever we rigidly adhere to notions of what is right and best. This is when we most often fall victim to the negative effects of dogma.
I eventually gave up being a member of Nursing Mothers because of the inadvertent and non intended stigma about non breastfeeding women it propagated. Increasingly I found it very hard to promote the advantages of breast without 'putting down' the choices of other women, thereby running the risk of damaging their self esteem. Back then if you didn't breast feed you weren't an adequate or good enough, or even intelligent, mother! Tough call. I couldn't be part of a support system that didn't support all mothers.
I find the same problem in home education. The attitude home education is best for all students and always produces excellent or best results in parents of schooled children feeling attacked for their choices. Whilst we know the benefits of home education, we cannot say for sure if it is good for all students and families. The HIV situation in Africa has proven that breastfeeding can be lethal to some babies. Perhaps we need to err on the side of caution when selling the benefits of homeschooling to unwary and vulnerable parents. There are many families out there for whom this educational solution just won't work.
In the final analysis, the only thing we can do is put all the information on the table, make it freely available, both unbiased and biased information, and let people make the decisions for themselves.
Was this article helpful? Was it worth $1.00 to you? Your gift of $1 or more helps to keep this site operating offering encouragement and reassurance to families wanting better outcomes for their children.
Beverley Paine with her children, and their home educated children, relaxing at home.
Together with the support of my family, my aim is to help parents educate their children in stress-free, nurturing environments. In addition to building and maintaing this website, I continue to create and manage local and national home educating networks, help to organise conferences and camps, as well as write for, edit and produce newsletters, resource directories and magazines. I am an active supporter of national, state, regional and local home education groups.
Welcome to the
World of Home Education and
We began educating our children in 1985, when our eldest was five. In truth, we had helped them learn what they need to learn since they were born. I am a passionate advocate of allowing children to learn unhindered by unnecessary stress and competition, meeting developmental needs in ways that suit their individual learning styles and preferences. Ours was a homeschooling, unschooling and natural learning family! There are hundreds of articles on this site to help you build confidence as a home educating family. We hope that your home educating adventure is as satisfying as ours was! Beverley Paine
The information on this website is of a general nature only and is not intended as personal or professional advice. This site merges and incorporates 'Homeschool Australia' and 'Unschool Australia'.
Home education is a legal alternative
Without revenue from advertising
Thank you for visiting!
Beverley Paine, The Educating Parent
The opinions and articles included on this website are not necessarily those of Beverley and Robin Paine,
nor do they endorse or recommend products listed in contributed articles, pages, or advertisements.
This website uses browsing cookies and conducts other means to collect user information in order to display contextual ads.
Site Map. Text and images on this site © All Rights Reserved 1999-2018.